ALIEN3 wasn't received very well by the general population, I don't blame them for that,
the first time I saw it, I didn't really care for it much either. But I've gotten to love it
just as much as the other films in the series. The thing is, that Fincher filmed it more
as a piece of art than the other directors had done, which created a different mood altogether.
Whether you like that mood is up to yourself.
The only real problem with ALIEN3, is that it has major holes in the plotline,
such simple things as:"How the devil did that egg get onboard the Sulaco?" and stuff like that.
It's a shame, it could have been a larger success if filmed for a larger audience.
Maybe the problem, is that people expected something near ALIENS, and got something near ALIEN.
Maybe they had gotten accustomed to the kind of films most stars throw out into the streets, and
that's action films. A shame, because ALIEN3 really has it's bright moments, especially the birth
of the "bambi" Alien and the death of Ripley (speaking in the way they're filmed, not what they
portray). Also the inventive way of showing the Alien POV (Point-Of-View) to the viewers.
A lot of people also think, that Fincher displayed the characters of the film like nothing
more than shadows in the dark. He killed them off fairly quick, and without hesitation. Just
as you think Clemens might just survive, he's killed. But I think that Fincher actually had
quite a nice range of characters, he was deviating quite a bit from the previous films, and that's
good (in my opinion)